Sewer Lateral Replacement: Should You Hire a Plumber or an Excavation Contractor?

You need your sewer lateral replaced. Maybe you're buying a house and the inspection revealed a problem. Maybe you're selling and a sewer camera inspection uncovered tree roots. Or maybe you're dealing with recurring backups and have finally discovered what's happening underground.
Whatever the reason, you've learned that the pipe connecting your home to the sewer system needs to be replaced.
Now comes the next question: Who should you hire? A plumber or an excavation contractor? Both can be legitimate options. But depending on the work involved, the difference between the two can affect how the project is organized, how many people need to be on-site, and what you ultimately pay.
At K+L Construction, we specialize in excavation and underground pipe installation and replacement, including sewer laterals. Here's what homeowners should understand before deciding who to hire.
First, What Is a Sewer Lateral?

A sewer lateral is the underground pipe that connects your home to the municipal’s public sewer main or a private sewage system, carrying wastewater from toilets, sinks, showers, washing machines, and other plumbing fixtures away from the house.
Over time, sewer laterals can develop problems such as:
Tree roots entering through joints or cracks
Cracked, deteriorating, or damaged pipe
Sections that have settled and created low spots, commonly called bellies
Pipe failures that cause recurring blockages or sewer backups
A sewer camera inspection can help identify what's happening inside the line. If the findings indicate that the lateral needs replacement, your next step is choosing the right contractor for the work.
Side note - it’s always a good idea to get a sewer camera inspection when considering buying or selling a home, especially with an older house.
What’s the difference between a Plumber and an Excavation Contractor?

Plumbers are trained professionals who specialize in plumbing systems and pipework. Depending on their services, certifications and experience, they may offer sewer lateral replacement as part of their work.
However, not every plumber performs excavation themselves. If the job requires digging, a plumber who doesn't excavate will need to hire an excavation contractor to handle that portion.
An Excavation Contractor handles sitework, or ground level and below. This may include excavation, utilities, water management, and more. Be sure you’re getting an estimate from one who also performs underground pipe work and isn't dirt work only.
At K+L Construction, sewer lateral replacement is part of our normal work. We understand that installing the pipe is only one part of the job. The trench must also be excavated appropriately, the pipe installed to the required specifications and grade, and the area backfilled and restored.
The important question isn't whether a plumber or contractor is qualified. It's whether you need to hire two businesses to complete work that one qualified contractor could handle.
Why Does Excavation Experience Matter?

Underground pipework involves more than connecting sections of pipe. The contractor also needs to account for trench depth, pipe slope, bedding material, backfill, compaction, and the condition of the surrounding soil.
Poor installation or inadequate backfill can contribute to settlement, more broken pipes, and other problems. An experienced excavation contractor understands how the trench and the soil around the pipe affect the finished installation.
Excavation experience can also be particularly useful when a job involves deeper trenches, difficult access, road crossings, pavement restoration, or work near existing utilities.
For projects that require road work, permits, or municipal coordination, make sure your contractor has the appropriate qualifications and experience for those specific requirements.
So, Who Should You Hire?

The short answer: hire a contractor who is qualified to handle the full scope of your project.
A plumber may be the right choice, especially if they have their own excavation crew or manage the entire job efficiently.
An excavation contractor who has sewer experience may be a particularly practical choice, especially if your plumber subcontracts the excavation anyway.
Neither option is automatically right for every situation. What matters is the contractor's experience, qualifications, scope of work, and ability to complete the job properly.
Remember, every business has overhead costs factored into each job, and you're also paying for every person on or involved in the job. If you can find one company to do it all, you'll save yourself on both labor and overhead.
The final price can depend on the length and depth of the pipe, soil conditions, accessibility, existing utilities, permitting requirements, road or driveway restoration, and the specifications for the replacement pipe.
When comparing estimates, don't look at the total price alone. Make sure each estimate covers the same work, including:
Excavation and removal of the existing pipe, and whether they plan to replace the whole pipe, or the broken part.
Replacement pipe and installation - including type and length of pipe.
Required bedding material
Backfill and compaction
Permits and inspections, where applicable
Driveway, road, lawn, or other surface restoration
Any additional work identified during excavation
A lower initial estimate isn't necessarily the better value if important parts of the job are excluded.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I still hire an excavator if my township requires a licensed plumber?
Possibly! It's common for excavators to have a plumber they work with for these situations. Just ask!
What questions should I ask to know if an excavator is qualified?
Ask questions like "What is your experience in sewer and septic work?"
and "Will you be checking my township's specific regulations for bedding stone, slope, etc?"
Learn More about Sewer Lateral Replacement
Read more about projects we have completed:
Sewer Lateral Replacement in Berks, Bucks, Montgomery & the Lehigh Valley

K+L Construction provides sewer lateral replacement and underground excavation services throughout Berks County, Bucks County, Montgomery County, the Lehigh Valley, and surrounding areas in Southeastern Pennsylvania.
Whether a home inspection uncovered a problem, tree roots have damaged an existing line, or you're dealing with a failing sewer lateral, we can help you understand the replacement work involved.
Need a Sewer Lateral Replaced?
If you have an inspection report or already know your sewer line needs replacement, reach out to K+L Construction to discuss your project.
Fill out our online estimate request form to tell us about your project and request an estimate.
Let's get your underground pipework taken care of.
K+L Construction — getting it right from the ground down





Comments